Under the reverence due to this sacrament, nothing touches it but the dedicated things, which is why, for touching this Sacrament, are enshrined corporal and the chalice and the priest's hands "(III, q. 82, a. 3). by Michael Davies
What should be extraordinary has become the norm, and what should be the norm has become extraordinary
The introduction of communion hand was invariably followed by the introduction of extraordinary ministers of the Eucharist. But contrary to the communion in the hand, which was accepted in the first days of the Church, the use of extraordinary ministers during Mass has no historical precedent. Shred of evidence can be relied on to prove that Holy Communion was ever given for the liturgy but by a bishop, priest or deacon.
In the first centuries there is evidence of cases, but always outside the liturgy.
For the thirteenth century was already an established tradition that only those who had been specifically dedicated for that purpose could come into contact with the Blessed Sacrament until it had been placed in the mouth of the communicant. St. Thomas Aquinas (1225-1274) wrote about this (III, q. 82, a. 3):
"The distribution of the Body of Christ belongs to the priest for three reasons. First, because he embodies in persona Christi. But as Christ consecrated His body in the Supper, He also gave the other to participate in it. Consequently, as the consecration of the Body of Christ belongs to the priest, just as their distribution also corresponds to it. Second, because the priest is the intermediary established between God and the people, which, as it belongs to offer people the gifts of God, he also belongs to relieve the people the gifts consecrated. Third, because by virtue of reverence due to this sacrament, nothing touches it but the dedicated things, which is why, for touching this sacrament, consecrate the body and the chalice and the priest's hands. Consequently, no one is permitted to touch it, except if necessary, for example, if you were to fall to the ground or other emergency. "
The document authorizing the introduction of extraordinary ministers of the Eucharist is an Instruction of the Sacred Congregation for Divine Worship, 29 January 1973, entitled Immensae Caritatis. She authorized the use of extraordinary ministers "in cases of genuine need." This is the list of cases, but only if:
a) no priest or deacon
b) they are prevented from administering Holy Communion because of another pastoral ministry, health reasons or old age;
c) the number of the faithful to receive Holy Communion is such that the celebration of Mass or distribution of the Eucharist outside Mass may be unduly prolonged.
The instruction states:
"Because these powers are granted only for the spiritual good of the faithful and for cases of genuine need, are reminded priests that they are not excused from the task distribute the Eucharist the faithful who legitimately ask, and especially to give it to the sick. "
is hard to imagine the existence of circumstances that justify the use of extraordinary ministers is not the case in mission lands. Although it is possible that these circumstances are given when a priest in charge of vast areas will be physically impossible to administer Holy Communion to all the sick and dying who need it. Of course, the good of souls should have any priority, so if you have the choice between someone who dies without receiving the sacrament or receive a layman, certainly the latter is preferable, always assuming that the priest you have found it physically impossible to attend. Obviously, in such circumstances it is desirable that the dying man could go to the sacrament of penance, but again, when it is physically impossible for an act of perfect contrition is sufficient, even in case of mortal sin.
But there is no comparison between these truly extraordinary circumstances and practice, too common today in many countries to instruct hundreds of laity in each diocese the performance of a task, as John Paul II has emphasized, should be normally " a privilege of the ordained. " And not infrequently sees priests sit in their chairs presidential leading edges or even acting as directors of the rows of communicants as elite members of the parish administered Holy Communion to those, perhaps shortening the duration of the Mass five minutes or less.
The fact that a person is selected as an extraordinary minister can certainly contribute to the esteem of those who are desirous of obtaining jobs that place them apart (and above) of their coparroquianos. This phenomenon manifested itself as soon as they began to allow the laity to read the Epistle or take part in the offertory procession. Priests who have not acknowledged these practices have frequently been the subject of complaints to the bishop by lay eager to achieve the status that these trades will bring.
The faithful who have seen the acceptance of such extraordinary ministers in their parishes have noticed that the correct term "extraordinary" is rarely used. However, this is the official term used in Immensae Caritatis and the new Code of Canon Law. The terms "secular" or "special" applies mainly to refer to these ministers because it allows disguise the fact that the use of such ministers should be an extraordinary event, something that only rarely, if ever it were the case, is could be in mission lands. It is hard to imagine a priest, say, in the United States, with so many pressing obligations that do not have time to take Holy Communion to the sick. If the weight of administrative tasks it became so heavy, that really is an area where you can get help from the laity. This situation, in which priests are overwhelmed by activities that lay people can play while they take the proper task of the priests to take Holy Communion to the sick, is positively exotic epitomización perfectly the ethos of Western Church today.
As to the undue extension of the Mass in parishes with large membership, there is usually another priest for help. And even if there were other priests, and the administration of the Eucharist was long and it is hard to imagine that it is unduly prolonged. The priest may encourage the faithful to make in those moments, a perfect preparation and thanksgiving for the privilege of receiving their Savior. Could any such time spent Thanksgiving be unduly prolonged? Rarely extend beyond ten or fifteen minutes. If you consider how long it uses the average Catholic in watching TV every day, can a thanksgiving of fifteen minutes considered unduly prolonged?
Unfortunately, the Vatican's policy was expressed in vague terms. The phrase "unreasonably prolonged" can mean five or fifty minutes, depending on who the interpreter. Through these interpretations, therefore Immensae caritatis opened the door to the proliferation of extraordinary ministers. Linked to the introduction of Communion under both kinds at Mass on Sundays, this explosion of extraordinary ministers rivers has reached epidemic proportions, which has been possible, although not strictly authorized by Immensae Caritatis. Very few bishops provided the minimum compliance to the admonition of Pope John Paul II in his letter Coenae Dominicae of February 24, 1980:
"Touching the sacred species and distribute them with their own hands is a privilege of the ordained."
"When ordinary ministers (bishops, priests and deacons) are present in the Eucharistic celebration, whether or not held in sufficient numbers, and are not prevented from doing so under other ministries, extraordinary ministers of the Eucharist are not allowed to distribute communion to themselves or to the faithful. "
On the contrary, some bishops, or liturgical bureaucrats who handle, show great enthusiasm for Communion under both species, mainly because it gives them an excuse to increase the epidemic of extraordinary ministers to make a real pest. In 1987, in a letter that is included at the end of this work, the Holy See sought to restrict the spread of this pest, but with little success.
No impartial observer can deny that it has expanded a broad decline in reverence to the Blessed Sacrament since Vatican II. In "Dominicae Coenae" Pope John Paul II condemns these cases:
"We have heard of cases of deplorable lack of respect towards the Eucharistic species, cases that are attributable not only to individuals guilty of such conduct, but also to the pastors of the Church that have not been vigilant enough regarding the attitude of the faithful towards the Eucharist. "
The Holy Father concluded this letter with his famous apology to the faithful by the scandal and disturbance to those who have been subjected over the veneration due to the Blessed Sacrament:
"And I pray the Lord Jesus that in future we can avoid in our way we conduct this sacred mystery anything which might undermine or mislead in any way the sense of reverence and love that exists in our faithful people. "
The sense of reverence and love of the faithful for the Blessed Sacrament will inevitably be weakened in any diocese where the bishop, by conviction or weakness, has allowed the use of extraordinary ministers of the Eucharist when there are no extraordinary circumstances, what truth is that such circumstances do not exist in ninety-nine percent of the parishes where such ministers are employed. What should be extraordinary has become the norm, and what should be the norm has become extraordinary. Such is the state of Catholicism in the Roman Rite today.
We are witnessing not simply a decrease on respect for the Blessed Sacrament, where that connection still exists, but a decline in respect and appreciation of the sacredness of the priesthood, where the respect and appreciation that already exist. Very few young Catholics see their priests as another Christ, alter Christi, a man who is different not merely in degree but in essence the rest of the faithful, a man whose primary mission is to enter the shrine and perform the sacred rites that only he can perform. In Dominicae Coenae Pope John Paul II reminded Catholics:
"Do not forget the primary office of priests, who have been consecrated by their ordination to represent Christ the Priest: For this reason his hands and his words and will have become the direct instruments of Christ. Through this fact, that is, as ministers of the Eucharist, they have a primary responsibility Dad the sacred species, because it is a total liability. They offer the bread and wine, they consecrate, and then distribute the sacred species to the participants of the meeting who wish to receive ... How eloquent, therefore, even if not ancient custom, the rite of anointing of the hands in our organization America, and that these hands is necessary precisely a special grace and power the Holy Spirit! "
INVOLVING THE HOLY SEE
In September 1987 the Holy See sent letters to the presidents of several episcopal conferences on the subject of extraordinary ministers, urging them to prevent abuse of the rule making of what should be extraordinary. We include here the full text of the letter sent to Archbishop John L. May, president of the National Conference of Catholic Bishops of the United States.
As you can imagine, the document was completely ineffective, but at unless it provides evidence that the Holy See is aware of the extent of the abuses of extraordinary ministers (there have been "numerous reports of such abuse "), even if you were unable to do anything to stop them.
September 21, 1987.
Very Reverend John L. CNOC President
May 1312, Massachusetts Avenue, NW Washington DC 20005
Dear Archbishop May:
Cardinal Prefect of the Congregation of the Sacraments, in a circular letter to all representatives of the pope, has issued the following clarification concerning extraordinary ministers of the Eucharist.
the power given to the laity enabling them to distribute Holy Communion as extraordinary ministers of the Eucharist (Fees 23O, 3; 9IO, 2) is undoubtedly one of the most appropriate forms of participation in the liturgy of the Church. On the one hand, this privilege has provided a real help for both the celebrant and the congregation at times where it has a large number of people to receive Holy Communion. But on the other hand, in certain instances, there have been significant abuses of this privilege. Such abuses have led to situations where the extraordinary nature of this ministry is lost. Sometimes it seems, even if the designation as extraordinary ministers became a kind of prize to reward those who have worked for the Church.
Cardinal Mayer warns that the abuse of which he speaks happen when:
- extraordinary ministers of the Eucharist communion usually distributed along with the celebrant, either when the number of communicants do not need your help, as when other celebrants present or o-ordinary ministers centers available, although not celebrating;
- given the extraordinary ministers of Holy Communion to themselves and the faithful as the celebrant and concelebrated-if any-are inactive.
After receiving numerous reports of such abuse, the congregation decided to seek una interpretación auténtica de los Cánones pertinentes a la Pontificia Comisión para la interpretación auténtica del Código de Derecho Canónico. Se formuló la siguiente duda:
“Utrum minister extraordinarius Sacrae Communionis, ad norman cann. 9IO, par. 2 et 23O, par. 3, deputatus suum munus suppletorium exercere possit etiam cum praesentes sint in ecclesia, etsi ad celebrationem eucharisticam non participantes, ministri ordinarii qui non sint quoque modo impediti”?.
La Comisión Pontificia trató la cuestión en su sesión Plenaria del 20 de febrero de 1987 y respondió: NEGATIVO.
Esta interpretación authentic was approved by the Holy Father on June 15, 1987, who accordingly gave instruction to the Congregation for the Sacraments of communicating the decision to the episcopal conferences.
The response of the Pontifical Commission clearly states that when ordinary ministers (bishops, priests and deacons) are present in the Eucharistic celebration, whether or not celebrating, and are in sufficient number and are not prevented from doing so under other ministries, extraordinary ministers of the Eucharist are not allowed to distribute communion to themselves or to the faithful.
Finally, Cardinal Mayer asked to convey these directives to the members of the Episcopal Conference.
With my expressions of appreciation and good wishes, I remain yours in Christ,
Pio Laghi Apostolic Pro-Nuncio
INSTRUCTION ON
SOME QUESTIONS ABOUT THE COLLABORATION OF THE LAY FAITHFUL IN THE SACRED MINISTRY OF PRIESTS
Article 8
The extraordinary minister of Holy Communion
The non-ordained faithful, as has long been cooperating in various environments with the sacred pastoral ministers so that "the gift ineffable Eucharist is always known and more deeply involved in its saving effect with ever greater intensity. "(95)
is a liturgical service that meet specific needs of the faithful, intended especially for the sick and liturgical assemblies in which are particularly numerous faithful who wish to receive Holy Communion.
§ 1. The canonical discipline concerning extraordinary minister of Holy Communion should be, however, when properly applied to avoid creating confusion. It states that the ordinary minister of Holy Communion is the Bishop, a priest or a deacon (96) while being extraordinary ministers is the acolyte established, it is true to the standard delegate can. 230, § 3. (97).
A non-ordained faithful, if they suggest reasons of real necessity, may be delegated by the diocesan bishop as special minister to distribute Holy Communion even outside the celebration of the Eucharist, ad actum vel ad tempus or stable mode, using for this the appropriate liturgical form of blessing. In exceptional circumstances and contingencies may be granted permission ad actum by the priest who presides over the Eucharistic celebration (98).
§ 2. For the extraordinary minister, during the Mass, to distribute the Holy Communion, it is necessary that these ministers are not regular or that, these, although present, are truly disabled (99). Can develop the same charge even when, because of the large participation of the faithful who wish to receive Holy Communion, the Mass would last over failure of regular ministers. (100)
It is custom and unique substitution (101) and must be exercised according to law. To this end it is appropriate for special rules emanating diocesan bishop, in close harmony with universal law of the Church, governing the exercise of such request. It must provide, among other things, Faithful to delegate to that commission is properly instructed on the doctrine of the Eucharist, on the nature of their service on the headings to be observed with due reverence for such an August Sacrament and the discipline on admission to Communion.
order not to cause confusion must be avoided and removed some practices that have been building for some time in some Churches, such as:
- the communion of extraordinary ministers like celebrants;
- associate, to renewal of the promises of the priests in the S. Holy Thursday Chrism Mass, other categories of faithful who renew religious vows are mandated or extraordinary ministers of Communion.
- the habitual use of extraordinary ministers in the SS. Masses, arbitrarily extending the concept of 'strong turnout. "
Notes:
(95) Sacred Congregation for the Discipline of the Sacraments, Instruction Immensae Caritatis (January 29, 1973), preface: AAS 65 (1973), p. 264.
(96) Cf CIC, can. 910, § 1, cf. also John Paul II, Letter Dominicae Coenae (24 February 1980), n. 11: AAS 72 (1980), p. 142.
(97) Cf CIC, can. 910, § 2.
(98) Cf Congregation for the Discipline of the Sacraments, Instruction Immensae Caritatis, n. 1: lc, p. 264; Missale Romanum, Appedix: Ritus ad deputandum
ministrum S. Ad actum Communionis distribuendae; Pontificale Romanum: De institutione Lectorum et acolythorum.
(99) Pontifical Commission for the Authentic Interpretation of Canon Law, Response (June 1, 1988): AAS 80 (1988), p. 1373.
(100) Sacred Congregation for the Discipline of the Sacraments, Instruction Immensae Caritatis, n. 1: lc, p. 264; Sacred Congregation for the Sacraments and Divine Worship, Instruction Inaestimabile donum, n. 10: lc, p. 336.
(101) The dog. 230, § 2 and § 3 of the ICC says liturgical services mentioned therein can be made by non-ordained faithful only "ex Deputation TEMPORARY 'or substitution.
.......
particular laws are repealed and the existing customs that are contrary to these standards, as well as any ad experimentum powers granted by the Holy See or any other authority subordinate to it.
The Supreme Pontiff, dated August 13, 1997, has specifically approved this general decree ordering its publication.
Vatican City, August 15, 1997. Solemnity of the Assumption of the Blessed Virgin Mary.
Congregation for the Clergy Dario Castrillon Hoyos
Pro-Prefect
Pontifical Council for the Laity
President James Francis Stafford
Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Cardinal Joseph
. Ratzinger Prefect
Congregation for Bishops Cardinal Bernardin. Prefect
Gantin
Congregation for Institutes of Consecrated Life and Societies of Apostolic Life
Eduardo Card. Mayor Martinez Somalo
Congregation for the Evangelization of Peoples, Cardinal Jozef
. Tomko Prefect
Pontifical Council for the Interpretation of Legislative Texts
President Julian Herranz
Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments
Jorge Arturo Medina Estévez Prefect Pro-