The Pope is being hampered by negative forces of resistance
present an interesting interview with Bishop Luigi Negri, Bishop of San Marino-Montefeltro, granted to La Voce di Romagna.
Excellency, the hallmark of his pontificate is the relationship between faith and reason, why insist on the liturgy?
The liturgy is the life of Christ that takes place in the Church and Christians involves existentially. The liturgy is not just a cult that rises from man to God, as in most of the formulations natural religious.
The liturgy is the large event held from the life, passion, death and resurrection that takes shape in the sacramental body and involves Christians in a substantial and fundamental way, making them belong to Christ and the Church through the sacraments of Christian initiation, and then accompanied them on the great options and the major stages of his life. In large vocational choices - marriage, order - or in the stages of life. However, the liturgy defend the factuality of Christ and the Church. So I have much gratitude to Professor De Mattei for his extraordinary book on the history of the Vatican II and pages devoted to a slow and inexorable "socialize" the liturgy, even before the Council, as if the value of the liturgy was in the possibility that the Christian people actively participate in an event that was then empty, in fact , its sacredness and ended up being an initiative of Catholic sociability.
And I think that plays in the liturgy the truth of faith because it plays great alternative that Benedict XVI has put the start of Deus Caritas Est: Christianity is not a religious ideology, not a draft moralist, but it is the encounter with Christ that remains and grows in the life of the Church and in the life of each Christian.
The liturgy makes present the fact of Christ in the flow and ebb of the generations: "Do this in remembrance of me." I think also the defense of a dogma exact consciousness depends on the truth that the liturgy is lived. In this sense, the Church has always affirmed that "lex orandi, lex credendi": the law of prayer that gives rise to the law of faith but above all the monitors in an appropriate and positive.
Two aspects seem central to the book, Ratzinger's theology of the liturgy "unfortunately verified the prevalence of a sense of the Mass as an assembly," a particular event or church group local "dinner by or both, participation is understood as the act of several persons who, according to the author sometimes becomes parody. And then the celebration to the people who, through a series of misunderstandings and misinterpretations "is presented today as the fruit of the liturgical renewal desired by the Council," writes the Pope. Consequences: the community as a circle closed in on itself and never before seen clericalization where everything converges on the celebrant.
I agree that the pope should continue to "reform the reform 'liturgy of the Council, use the words of Don Nicola Bux. But it must be said with extreme clear that the Pope is having trouble making this "reform of the reform." There are negative trends in resistance, even so passive. The liturgical reform after the Council coming most of the time is filled with pseudo-interpretations or exceptional circumstances have been invoked as a rule - just think of the problem of language or the distribution of Communion in the hand. There have been real "hits" of the Episcopal Conferences against Rome.
Certainly there were a weakness of the Vatican's reaction, probably due to tensions and counter tensions even within the structures that should govern the proper interpretation and application Council. Now, even taking into account the data constraints that a government of the Church must face realistically, the choice is between a sociologization of the liturgy - to say, proper operation of the laws and community behaviors Christians gathered to celebrate the Eucharist, which becomes the subject of the Eucharist rather than his interlocutor - and bring back to the center to the real subject of the Eucharist, which is Christ in person. The structure of the liturgical tradition and the Church Council has received, save the rights of Christ and Christ's presence. Then all This is done to deplete or reduce the awareness of the presence of Christ in favor of the way in which the community is present, it is a waste of the ultimate value of the liturgy, the ontological value, say Giussani, and therefore methodological and educational. In the time it entered into force for the first time the reform of Vatican II, a high Vatican personality - but I can not tell what is true, because I have read with my own eyes - and finally wrote that the celebration of the Mass again to be a "healthy Catholic arena of sociability."
Can you tell me, at least if it was a few steps more Monsignor Bugnini up?
Many steps up to Bishop Bugnini.
"In Italy, apart from a few honorable exceptions, the bishops and superiors of religious orders have opposed the implementation of the Motu proprio" said the vice president of the Pontifical Commission Ecclesia Dei to a year away from Summorum Pontificum, Benedict XVI that "liberalized" the traditional Tridentine liturgy. A very strong denunciation of disobedience of the Italian episcopate.
what extent we are in the implementation of the motu proprio? In his diocese, Are there celebrations of the liturgy in the extraordinary form of the Roman Missal of 1962?
I have tried to apply, in addition to receiving and clergy to explain to my sense of this Motu Proprio, in my opinion, is a possibility given to the Church who want to exploit a broader wealth and articulate what is available to everyone. It is as if the Pope had reopened the possibility of a liturgical celebration that the individual and the group feels more in line with its desire for growth and its principles. However, I must say that so far have missed the applicable rules, we are waiting for years.
basically so you can do today, where the bishop has obeyed, as in my case, are held not many but all those Masses that have been ordered, according to the method precisely identified by the Motu proprio. When the Pope said before that it is difficult to pass the "reform the reform" was precisely in mind a Motu proprio of the missing, more than three years of enactment, applicable dimensions. But I think that rejection, resistance, have been not so much about the motu proprio but although the fact that the liturgical reform of Vatican II, and the texts are interpreted and how the liturgy has been determined, it seems that can not be put into discussion. Resistance is about the very possibility, which in turn has opened the Pope, to have other forms of implementation of the liturgical and sacramental life: this is in question, not the applications. While the pope said, is a sacramental liturgical richness of the whole Church, if you want, you can access, not everything is redirected to a single form, in my opinion, there is a broad stratum of the church that believes that in However, the reform of Vatican II took everything I was before. Is that hermeneutics of discontinuity on which the Pope spoke very clearly and decisively.
Doxa According to a poll, 71 percent of normal Catholics would find itself in two forms coexist parish of the Roman rite, traditional and new. 40 percent of those who go to Mass every Sunday, if available in the parish, rather go every week to the Mass of St. Pius V. How do comments on these data, which must be taken with care as any survey?
I remain of the opinion that, beyond these facts, the Church must be very available to provide ways and means of participation in the life of Christ that apply in their diversity to the inevitable diversity that exists among men and among young people. I think we should encourage a sincere missionary enthusiasm. At a time when churches are empty and there are many difficulties for a proper understanding of the mystery of Christ and the Church, all I can provide to be used, but not to assert their own ideological choices! Traditionalism-progressivism shock no longer valid, and this improvement we are truly indebted to Benedict XVI. They are ideological opposites hypostatizes views, sensibilities, ways, instead of asking what works best for the mission of the Church and, therefore, to raise their children.
How Mass celebrated Don Luigi Giussani? What was your thinking on the liturgy and how was the reform?
Giussani
I have seen celebrating according to the rite of Saint Pius V, was celebrating with the deep awareness of being a protagonist in an event of grace that opened the hearts and lives of men. And I've seen celebrating according to the reformed liturgy, the same way. Giussani was to basics and, by nature, was not inclined to over-emphasize the individual. I can not say how he reacted to the reform because I do not remember that we talked about this, not between us, although we had had hundreds of hours of dialogue on all problems of life of the Church and society, and publicly. But the image of the liturgy that was being contained in that beautiful book "Dalla vissuta liturgy, a proposta. I think both the traditional liturgy as reformed liturgy, if kept in the identity that is recognized by the teacher, can ensure that life becomes a proposal of life: the liturgy is life, life of Christ with his , which becomes life proposal. I do not think he was willing to die to save the liturgy of St. Pius V but I do not - as I have known for fifty years together - you said once that the liturgy of Vatican II was the best. Rather, I think, as on other issues of Vatican II, had some difficulties of interpretation, as it is now recognized part of the vast majority of pastors and theologians smart. So true is that, after forty years, Benedict XVI says he now begins a true interpretation of the Council.
What features will the religious and church of the Pope's visit to San Marino in 2011?
There will be a celebration of the Mass in San Marino for the whole diocese, in the Serravalle Stadium on the morning of June 19, according to an informal program that gradually is becoming official.
These days you have been observing a journalist in a newspaper lay on the disparity between his personality - "diamond" - and the diocese that has been entrusted, defined "Diocese of operetta."
I am grateful to the journalist for the compliments, a little undeserved, I have done, not only here but also at other times. In the winding roads that end in the provision of a certain particular church, or a responsibility also central to the conduct of the Church, no, let me, is so naive as not to know that there are movements, counter-movements, reactions, counter-reactions, interests, have great weight. I've written anything about careerism in my column "in season and" in Studi Cattolici, so all this phenomenology of the presence of political attitudes do not find it so unusual or outrageous. I am of that generation of priests and bishops who believes that, anyway, finally, and above all these trends, counter-currents, friends, crossed vetoes, is the will of God interpreted by the Holy Father. When the Holy Father calls you, you can be sure it is God who calls you, and if you call that reality that calls you, is because God considers what is best for you at that time. It is with this mood, very devoted to the will of God and very happy, I am a bishop of a diocese defined "Operetta" by someone, but I have taken this diocese presence and visibility in the Italian ecclesial and social context, and not only.
Moreover, many appointments will people do not always live up to the responsibilities entrusted to them, a serious problem today, when the Church should give up the proposed cultural and pastoral. Excellency, do not you think that this is an obstacle or an impediment to the mission of the Church? Bishop Negri
But here is not responding and closes the dialog. She looks at me deeply with her clear eyes and falls silent. It is the day of Saint Lucy, the evening is succumbing to the "longest night." In Domagnano down the first flakes of snow. In contrast to above, in Rimini, everything melts in water.