Monday, August 28, 2006

Cover Letter Examples For Trainee Dental Nurse

coauthorship and Complicity (differences)

22,327 No


SUPREME COURT CRIMINAL APPEAL BOARD OF

Magistrate: Dr. Siegfried ESPINOSA PÉREZ
Approved
Act No. 21


Bogotá, DC, March 9, two thousand six.
"the cassation in the May 22, 2003, File No. 17457, the Board conducted a historical review relevant case law on the positions that have been held for more than two decades to differentiate the concepts of conspiracy and complicity count, which by their relevance to elucidate the case under discussion, is remembered this time: "(...)

basis of the legal existence and co-authored with the aim of distinguishing between perpetrators and accomplices, said September 9, 1980:

"'will be co-authors who, despite having performed functions themselves do not shape the crime, have acted as partners in a common enterprise-understanding of one or more facts, which, therefore, all owned or jointly own, and be accomplices who, without having done any act or omission by itself constitute a crime or crimes in participating, providing collaboration and support in what they consider foreign offense (MP Alfonso Reyes Echandía).

"Shortly after, he returned to say

" 'Where are several people who jointly run the offense, receive a grade of 'sponsors', in which case there is obviously a plurality of authors. On the way the authors call co incongruity is not any, nor substantial error "(August 11, 1981, MP Alfonso Reyes Echandía).

" A few years later, emphasized the presence of conspiracy in the Criminal Code of 1980, when he stated that:

"The conspiracy in the field of criminal participation can not be understood as a legal phenomenon that incorporates up confuse one acts performed by various authors ... The co-author remains, even if hypothetically deleting another entry .. . '(November 23, 1988, MP Lisandro Martínez Zúñiga).

"For if there is uncertainty, the Court was still more emphatic on May 10, 1991:

"'The laws that give preferential host the domain theory of action (for others, through different routes but converge to the same objective, the efficient cause or the conditio sine qua non, etc) are out this vocation with terms that imply (vgr. cooperate in the execution of the act with an act without which it would have been made). But those who read our articles and 24 ... 23 ... can not find that meaning, because the articles are more inclined to include a larger number of participants, as authors, the performers usually think or imagine. The restrictive view of authorship (Only those which are directly run the typical action mandated by law), has never found support in our doctrine and jurisprudence. On the contrary prevails extensively, which is not intended, as its name implies, reduce the number of authors, but to extend ... With this trend our status is ascribed to the legislative and hermeneutics which seeks to prevail in today's world of criminal law: secondary complicity in retreat under consideration, in particular, "to integrate into the authorship of all activities under a mutual agreement or plan, which generates a responsibility ... 'in solidum' of all participants, whatever the act of intervention " (MP Gustavo Gómez Velásquez).

"This jurisprudential tradition has not changed. And it has not changed, it is logical opposite the Criminal Code of 1980. Recently, therefore, repeated the tradition with these words:

"'Contrary to what the appellant considers the concept of co-creation is not a case law, because if the voices of the dictionary, so you must understand the' Author or author to another or others', it is unquestionable that this is not an invention, or that the Board legislate, because, ultimately, co-author is an author, only holding the event in the company of others. Thus, it is clear that there was no default any legislative and Article 23 of the Criminal Statute of 1980 envisaged within the concept of authorship, the realization of behavior by one or more persons. The natural and obvious meaning of words does not become indispensable that the provision should include the definition of co, whenever a variable of the author '(Judgement of September 12, 2002, establishment number 1740)'. "

On the same occasion [1] , the Court also highlighted the difficulty that it had become clear doctrinal level about the criteria to distinguish the authorship of complicity, especially when the partners involved consumptive at the time of the offense, as is the case now before the Board, an aspect that was clarified that: "(...)

enough, however, to clear the misunderstanding and make clear objectivity legal distinction clear in either case, if the actor is linked finalistic or not performing the behavior. In the first scenario, where further collaboration provides an offense which is a part, because of its commitment to objective and subjective results, it is a co-author. But if that aid is merely external coadyuvancia the purposes of the members of the joint venture, partnership stripped of soul with the purposes last of the direct perpetrators, who acts and is complicit in the offense. "

According to this conclusion, the Board reiterates today, simply combine objective and subjective elements in the consummation of behavior, to distinguish the authorship and complicity, to the extent that a person can be considered co-author of a crime, not only demands their unconditional willingness to do it, but their objective contribution, ie the importance of their contribution to the execution phase, as this is what ultimately determines the so-called "co-domain of fact", meaning "done" the causal process is about behavior starts.

Indeed, as recalled by the Assistant Attorney General in his opinion, according to the "domain theory fact, very useful to differentiate the two forms of participation, has written that found in building" (.. .) continue, stop or pause, by its conduct, the conduct of the type " [2] . Therefore, if several individuals who attend pre-arranged conducting unlawful behavior, to set up co-authored the contribution required to be essential, and to materialize during the typical run.
Hence, only those who may be overlooking the fact had the author, while the accomplice is one who simply provides assistance or provide support that is of significant importance for the realization of the wrongful conduct, ie without the domain part of the fact itself
[1] 17,457 cassation ruling of May 22, 2003. Klaus
Roxin. Authorship and mastery of fact in criminal law, Madrid, Marcial Pons, 1998, p.42

0 comments:

Post a Comment