Process 19746 not
SUPREME COURT Criminal Appeals Chamber Magistrate
Lombardi Dr. EDGAR TRUJILLO
Approved Minutes No.03
"On the other hand Article 23 of Act 599 of 2000 defines guilt as a form of criminal offense that is configured when the typical result is a product of the breach of duty of care objective, the agent should have foreseen to be expected, or having provided trusted to avoid it.
regulation with which the legislation was in line with the jurisprudence of this court that the breach had been claiming that the objective duty of care was the key criterion for charging on the reckless crimes.
4.1. So then, the target rate from the offense shall be composed of the elements that make up the factual and descriptive rather than normative.
4.1.1. The subject may be indefinite or qualified embezzlement as with the condition requiring fault public servant.
4.1.2. The action, resulting in the execution of a behavior aimed at obtaining a different result under the appropriate type.
4.1.3. Requires the presence of a physical result is not known and loved by the author, who served as a starting point to identify the objective care. This means it will be exceptional for a type of this class without material result.
4.1.4. The violation of objective duty of care. The author must engage in the behavior as would a reasonable and prudent person put in place the agent, so if you do not work under such requirements violate the objective duty of care. Element
with which it is intended that compliance with the requirements of care decrease the level of risk to the legal with the performance of hazardous activities, which is known as the tolerable risk (in areas such as traffic, medicine and work).
Given that there is a list of duties of care, the judicial officer must go to the various sources that indicate the configuration of the breach of duty of care in each case. Among them:
4.1.4.1. The rules of legal order or regulation pertaining to land transport, maritime, air and river, and labor regulations aimed at disciplining the good progress sources of risk.
4.1.4.2. The principle of trust that arises from this instrument, and that is that they behave in traffic in accordance with the rules can and must trust that all participants in the same traffic will too, unless that in substance it may be assumed otherwise.
maxim extends to the areas of work served by the division of functions and areas of everyday life, in which the act of individuals depends on the behavior assumed by others.
4.1.4.3. The criterion of the average man, because of which the judicial officer may assess the behavior compared with what would have observed a prudent and diligent in the position of the author. If the subject come from the agent remains within those parameters there is no violation of the duty of care, but whether the proceed beyond recklessness always converge other typical budgets.
4.1.4. Causal link or nexus determination. The transgression of the objective duty of care and the typical result must be linked by a relation of determination, ie, the violation should produce the result ..
4.2. Subjective. It is clear the presence of subjective content in the offense reckless, they are:
4.2.1. Volitional aspect. The typical result should not will be comprised of, or comprising a causality must do so other than the scheduled agent.
4.2.2. Cognitive aspect. Requires the possibility of knowing the danger that the conduct poses to the legal and predict the outcome under this cognition.
5. Given this legal framework is clear room for the occurrence of these elements:
regulation with which the legislation was in line with the jurisprudence of this court that the breach had been claiming that the objective duty of care was the key criterion for charging on the reckless crimes.
4.1. So then, the target rate from the offense shall be composed of the elements that make up the factual and descriptive rather than normative.
4.1.1. The subject may be indefinite or qualified embezzlement as with the condition requiring fault public servant.
4.1.2. The action, resulting in the execution of a behavior aimed at obtaining a different result under the appropriate type.
4.1.3. Requires the presence of a physical result is not known and loved by the author, who served as a starting point to identify the objective care. This means it will be exceptional for a type of this class without material result.
4.1.4. The violation of objective duty of care. The author must engage in the behavior as would a reasonable and prudent person put in place the agent, so if you do not work under such requirements violate the objective duty of care. Element
with which it is intended that compliance with the requirements of care decrease the level of risk to the legal with the performance of hazardous activities, which is known as the tolerable risk (in areas such as traffic, medicine and work).
Given that there is a list of duties of care, the judicial officer must go to the various sources that indicate the configuration of the breach of duty of care in each case. Among them:
4.1.4.1. The rules of legal order or regulation pertaining to land transport, maritime, air and river, and labor regulations aimed at disciplining the good progress sources of risk.
4.1.4.2. The principle of trust that arises from this instrument, and that is that they behave in traffic in accordance with the rules can and must trust that all participants in the same traffic will too, unless that in substance it may be assumed otherwise.
maxim extends to the areas of work served by the division of functions and areas of everyday life, in which the act of individuals depends on the behavior assumed by others.
4.1.4.3. The criterion of the average man, because of which the judicial officer may assess the behavior compared with what would have observed a prudent and diligent in the position of the author. If the subject come from the agent remains within those parameters there is no violation of the duty of care, but whether the proceed beyond recklessness always converge other typical budgets.
4.1.4. Causal link or nexus determination. The transgression of the objective duty of care and the typical result must be linked by a relation of determination, ie, the violation should produce the result ..
4.2. Subjective. It is clear the presence of subjective content in the offense reckless, they are:
4.2.1. Volitional aspect. The typical result should not will be comprised of, or comprising a causality must do so other than the scheduled agent.
4.2.2. Cognitive aspect. Requires the possibility of knowing the danger that the conduct poses to the legal and predict the outcome under this cognition.
5. Given this legal framework is clear room for the occurrence of these elements:
CLARIFICATION OF VOTING
As I am convinced that the purpose of unifying the law that is assigned by the legislature to the Chamber (Article 206 of Law 600 of 204 and 180 of Act 906 of 2004) is not limited only and exclusively in decisions dealing with special appeal, but which also includes other measures it adopts, in response to: i) limit its capacity as an ordinary criminal jurisdiction, ii) The nature of the auxiliary criterion is the case in accordance with Article 230 of the Constitution and, iii) The function that corresponds propaedeutic to ensure the effective right to equal those who have access to the administration of justice by judicial officers in the sense of being treated identically to cases against the same, proceed to record some details that I consider necessary to point define the scope of the concept "objective duty of care" if it is to analyze the configuration or not negligent or reckless crimes.
Thus, the ruling adopted by the Board on January 19, 2006 by which means, among other findings, it was decided to confirm the guilty verdict handed down by the High Court against the doctor Yopal VICENTE JAVIER BARRAGAN as author criminally BLACK responsible for the crime of embezzlement culpable states that "the author must perform the behavior as would a reasonable and prudent person put in place the agent, so if you do not work under such requirements violate the objective duty of care" and notes that from this "it is intended that compliance with the requirements of care decrease the level of risk to the legal to the exercise of hazardous activities, which is known as the tolerable risk."
turn is said to be not a list of duties of care can go to "the rules of legal or regulatory order pertaining to land transport, maritime, air and river, and labor regulations aimed at disciplining smooth running of the sources of risk. "
can also take into account "the principle of trust that arises with this instrument."
adds that also can be assessed "the standard of the average man (...) a prudent and diligent in the position of the author" and the "causal link", "ie, the violation should produce the result." Once highlighted
previous sections of the ruling on appeal taken by the Board, I believe that to fathom the scope of objective duty of care in a particular case whose occurrence causal link keeps the harmful outcome is ultimately produced should go first , as specified in the law, as with the Statutory Law on the Administration of Justice, the Code Single disciplinary or laws regulating the exercise of certain public offices.
Second, technical laws or lex artis, understood as the set of protocols set forth by professional associations to carry out certain activities, such as in medical activity or engineering.
Third, the "differential model" which involves verifying the correct procedure (prudence and diligence) that in accordance with the usual take on those who perform the work of one who is now investigated, from this, deduce whether or subjected to social expectations arising from their role.
It follows that you can go to the "criterion of the average man" (differential model) only when the lex artis law and provide no solution to the issue, to the extent that such verification criteria are residual and progressive, ie takes into account the following to the extent that the former can not reach a solution to the case under study.
also believe that the principle of trust, according to which, acting in accordance with the regulations pending the others a regulatory act constitutes a criterion for determining the duties of care they have for other people and it operates as objective or policy limit of liability for negligence.
I should also note that the "causal link", which corresponds to a merely naturalistic verification work between a cause and an effect as a result, it integrates an element useful for determining whether a violation of objective duty of care, as precisely that may appear in the configuration from the offense as a link between the negligent, unskilful, reckless, inexperienced or violation of regulations and the harmful result not intended by the agent but finally produced, hence, such causation is an element object Further follow-up assessment or accreditation of objective violation of duty of care, but not a member of it and the less serves as a criterion to set. Warned
above
find that in the case under consideration, the violation of duty of care of Dr. JAVIER BARRAGAN predicable BLACK was founded in the first criterion mentioned, that is, as established by law or regulations, specifically in Article 95 of Decree 2525 of 1993 and paragraph 7 of the Memorandum issued by the Attorney General's Office on January 14, 1994, which is responsible for regulating the procedures related to the control and custody of weapons made available to judicial officials.
In previous terms entered clarification let my vote, but first say that I share the above in order to decide that Dr. JAVIER BARRAGAN BLACK author should be condemned as criminally responsible for the wrongful embezzlement and other determinations made in that ruling.
With all attention,
MARINA BARON POLISHING
Judge
Date as above.
0 comments:
Post a Comment