Monday, August 28, 2006

Names For College Culturals

COMPLICITY


Process 23699 not


SUPREME COURT APPEAL BOARD OF CRIMINAL JUSTICE



ORLANDO PEREZ ALVARO
SPEAKER PINZÓN
APPROVED

ACTA No. 19 Bogotá, DC, twenty-eight (28) February, two thousand six (2006). CONSIDERATIONS



to the Board office is not likely to succeed because, besides not being true the assertion that Mr. Penagos Martinez was charged with having contributed only determined at the completion of the criminal offense, the attack rests on a mistaken understanding of the rule invoked as vulnerable.

For the first aspect, since an indictment of second instance, precisely when varied by the charge of accomplice which had been formulated as a determiner, the prosecution said that on Mr. PENAGOS

[s] or willful and criminal attitude was important to have influenced, in part to public servants who decide on the fate of state resources, and on the other, to promote their interests in exchange for the final placement of such resources in the hands of companies or individuals without sufficient funds ...".

The court ruling, the court stated:

Consequently, complicity is perfectly applicable to criminalize the conduct of the particular partner, when the author provides direct aid and mediate with the awareness that acting work before the crime during its commission, and even after depletion, but are more frequent instances of complicity given before the start of implementation. It is also possible, and therefore punishable, determination or instigation of complicity. A instigates B to C to help him commit crimes. When the forms of participation are equal no problem, as pointed MAURACH, so that "instigating instigation instigation the main fact of the latter and complicity in the complicity of the main event is an accomplice in the same" [1]

He added:

It should be understood as simple complicity the complicity of the determination, which is more benign participatory formula. But not only that, but because one can not be the conclusion. As the instigator of the accomplice is leading to complicity, which does not cross borders, the accomplice in the inducement is doing less than the instigator, whence it follows that just may be an accomplice. "Both the instigation of complicity and complicity in incitement will not be, according to that, mere complicity [2] .

Although the above seems to conclude that in fact he is accused Mr. PENAGOS have been complicit in the determination of which is not legally wrong, as we shall see later, the reflections from the assessment of the evidence the court did allow testimony glimpse a different perspective when he says, for example, that

[e] s clear that participated PENAGOS MARTÍNEZ actively in all the action to allow the appropriation of funds from the state agency, ie the allocation of resources by the institutions Inurbe solidarity, the choice of these and obviously in the snacks which are intended to make the previously contacted and negotiated entrepreneurs, who in return canceled the high fees required, a claim which has a large plot evidence the point of giving certainty.

So, it is indisputable that PENAGOS MARTÍNEZ gear was part of the relevant criminal mischief and have influenced consisting of some public servants who decide on the fate of state resources, and, secondly, in promoting their interests change the final placement of such resources in the hands of entities or persons without sufficient funds ...

On the second point, whether, in fact, the judges declared Mr. Penagos Martinez responsibility as an accomplice of the determiner and also the authors, it is evident that in any case the argument put forward by the applicant is wrong because 599 of the 2000 Act did not introduce the issue of authorship and participation policy change that points to apply for the acquittal of the accused.

While it is true that Decree 100 of 1980 considered in determining both as author and referred to in Article 23, while the accomplices alluded to in Article 24, it is true that the distinction established in Act 599 of 2000 between authors and participants, to place between the late both the determiner as an accomplice, had varied forms of criminal action but merely, as noted Mrs. Attorney, is a systematic classification in both groups in participation all authors concur that without the implementation of the criminal offense, either because those determined to commit, and because they help them to fruition.

Thus, the legislature of 2000 regulated in Article 29 matters related to the author, and decided:

Authors. He is the author who made the criminal offense by itself or by using another as an instrument. Co-authors

which, upon common agreement, act criminal division of the importance of input basis.

author who also acts as a member or authorized representative body or in fact a legal person, a collective without such an attribute, or a natural person whose representation voluntarily stop, and performs criminal offense, although the special elements that support the penalty of figure respective punishable not concur in it, but in the individual or collective entity represented.

The author in its various forms will incur the penalty for the criminal offense.

Article 30, however, spoke to participants to provide:

Unitholders. They have taken the determiner and the accomplice.

Who determines a person to perform the unlawful conduct will be punished for the offense.

who contribute to realization of unlawful behavior or provide further assistance by prior agreement or related to it, shall incur the penalty for the offense for a sixth reduced by half.

The participant that not having the special qualities required to attend the criminal in the making, it will lower the penalty in a quarter.

The applicant's mistake is obvious if one takes into account the contribution of the accomplice referred the law to the criminal offense, not the author. Remember the statute: Who contributes to the achievement of unlawful behavior. So it may happen that there accomplice determiner as well as incitement to complicity, as in the case of one who has moved to another to give death to a third party and the formation of criminal resolution helps another person who offers to ensure the escape of a murderer or remove traces of crime or , in an example given by Velasquez Velasquez, the son who assists the mother to induce it to her lover to kill her husband.

So the same author refers to variables that can record the action of an accomplice:

Finally, incitement and complicity can go with, it can happen otherwise. As mentioned, there may be abetting abetting (The mother instigates his son to provide him money to his pregnant girlfriend in order to inflict the abortion), but also complicit in instigating (the son is assisting the mother to induce her lover to legitimate to kill the husband). Likewise, a complicity can be done by several people, can speak of joint complicity or co-complicity (the two security guards in the bank informed the group of attackers on the security conditions inside the pit) is even conceivable complicity in abetting (the dealer will repair the weapon to its owner, that this is the providing the murderer). Similarly it is possible complicity in the attempt (Peter supplies John the number of the bank safe and this is caught by police when attempting to open) [3] .

no need to examine whether the various possibilities of involvement of the accomplice referred to the doctrine is consistent with the legal provisions, the fact is that, to reiterate the answer in case the Board has not only may a person is an accomplice of the determiner but Mr. Penagos Martinez was convicted of it precisely because they and the authors, as was credited with the sections of the steps that were left transcribed above.
[1] MAURACH, Reinhart. Law Treaty Criminal, T. I, Editorial Ariel, 1962, pag. 367.

[2] SALAZAR MARIN, Mario. Author and participant in the criminal injustice. Ed Themis, 1992. Bogotá.

[3] Velasquez Fernando Velasquez, Criminal Law, General Part, 2 ª. ed., Ed Themis, Bogotá, 1995, pp. 570-571.
Process

0 comments:

Post a Comment